TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A House Beautiful report describes designers turning more often to natural stone and porcelain instead of engineered quartz, citing aesthetics, performance expectations and worker-safety concerns. The source does not establish that quartz is broadly disappearing or that a California production ban has been enacted.
Some interior designers are steering clients away from engineered quartz toward quartzite, marble, granite, soapstone and porcelain, according to a House Beautiful report that cites design-industry sourcing data and concerns about fabrication workers’ exposure to crystalline silica. The shift is a reported change in preferences, not evidence that quartz countertops are disappearing from the market or that a nationwide restriction is imminent.
The report cites an annual National Kitchen & Bath Association trend report, saying 78 percent of designers are sourcing quartzite while fewer individuals are selecting quartz. It does not provide the survey’s full methodology, the comparison period, or a specific percentage decline in quartz selection, so the figure should not be read as a measure of how many kitchens use each material.
Designers interviewed by House Beautiful describe different reasons for recommending alternatives. New York-area designer Barrett Oswald says natural stone has more warmth and variation than engineered quartz. San Diego designer Kilian Camp says clients often reconsider quartz after seeing natural slabs, while Santa Barbara designer Jessica Risko Smith says some homeowners expect more from quartz’s stain resistance than the material can deliver.
The alternatives vary in cost and upkeep. The designers recommend marble and quartzite for their appearance, and Smith points to granite and soapstone as options for homeowners seeking natural stone with relatively manageable maintenance. Camp and Steven Cooper also recommend porcelain slabs for clients on a budget or for uses such as showers and fireplaces. These are designers’ recommendations, not a universal ranking of materials; suitability depends on the project and the homeowner’s priorities.
Material Choices Bring Trade-Offs
Countertops are a costly, disruptive part of a kitchen renovation, so a change in designer recommendations can affect decisions that homeowners may live with for years. The report’s central message is not that quartz has no place, but that buyers should weigh appearance, maintenance, cost and expected wear instead of assuming one engineered surface is the worry-free choice for every kitchen.
There is also a worker-safety issue distinct from the style debate. The report links concern about engineered-stone fabrication to crystalline silica exposure, which can cause silicosis. That concern relates to workers cutting and processing slabs; it should not be confused with a claim that an installed countertop poses the same exposure risk in normal household use. The source does not provide exposure measurements or a health assessment of finished countertops.
Products Worth Considering
Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra Upright Vacuum
Roborock Robot Vacuum and Mop with LiDAR Navigation and 10,000 Pa Suction
Bose SoundLink Flex Bluetooth Speaker (2nd Gen), Portable Waterproof Speaker, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Why Designers Are Reconsidering Quartz
Engineered quartz became popular partly because it offers consistent patterns, durability and relatively low maintenance, while imitating the veining of natural stone. The designers quoted in the report say those advantages can come with drawbacks: some prefer the irregularity of natural materials, and quartz’s stain resistance can be mistaken for stain-proof performance.
House Beautiful also reports that California is preparing to ban production of engineered quartz because of silicosis concerns among workers. The source characterizes the policy as reportedly in preparation; it does not identify a law, effective date, covered products or current implementation status. Camp says she views the issue as regional for now and predicts other states may take precautions, but that is her expectation, not an announced policy elsewhere.
““We’ve always felt that quartz lacks the depth, warmth, and individuality of natural stone.””
— Barrett Oswald, interior designer
The Scale of the Shift Is Unclear
The cited 78 percent figure concerns designers sourcing quartzite; the report does not state the survey’s sample, timeframe or year-over-year comparison. It therefore does not establish how quickly preferences are changing or whether quartz sales and installations are declining across the industry.
The status and scope of the reported California action also remain unclear from the source. It gives no official policy document or timetable. The report offers designer views and recommendations, not a market forecast, a material-by-material performance test, or evidence that quartz will be replaced broadly.
Watch for Policy and Market Data
Homeowners considering a renovation can compare samples and ask fabricators and installers about each material’s maintenance, staining, durability, price and care requirements. Anyone choosing stone should review the specific product and supplier guidance rather than relying on broad claims that a surface is maintenance-free.
For the wider trend, the next useful evidence would be fuller survey results and comparable sales or installation data. On the safety question, official California documents would clarify whether a production restriction has been adopted, which products it covers and when it would take effect. Until then, the reported shift is best understood as a designer preference trend alongside a developing policy concern, not a confirmed end to quartz countertops.
Key Questions
What materials are designers recommending instead of quartz?
The report names quartzite, marble, granite, soapstone and porcelain. The right choice depends on budget, appearance and tolerance for upkeep.
Is quartz being phased out?
The source describes some designers sourcing less quartz, but it does not show that quartz is broadly being discontinued or disappearing from the market.
Why are designers questioning quartz?
Interviewed designers cite its more uniform appearance, expectations that it will be stain-proof, and interest in natural materials that develop character over time.
Has California banned engineered quartz?
The report says California is reportedly preparing a production ban, but it does not confirm an enacted rule, its scope or an effective date.
Is porcelain a lower-cost alternative?
Two designers recommend porcelain slabs for clients on a budget, but the source gives no price comparisons. Costs can vary by product, installation and location.
Source: housebeautiful.com
