Broken Hearts Burger

My husband and I absolutely loved our first visit here! Amazing food, wonderful service in a great space. Will definitely be back!

Tried to beat the Rush on a Friday but it was unavoidable!
We where seated at the Bar and our Server was amazing. VERY ATTENTIVE! SHE was working by herself and handled the crowd and all the Happy people dining in so well. The food is amazing. This was our 3rd time there and the 1st time getting a Broken Heart Burger!
Wow they nailed a Smashburger out of the park!
We also had the Fried Pickles for an app. They where so delicous and the Breading they use is so tasty!
From the Warm Apple Cider to the Amazing Donuts we got to go I can Not say enough Great things about this Restaurant!
I also really can't say enough Great things about our server. She was Great to chat with when she had a quick second but I also take into consideration when your Not drinking alcohol your probably not going to to be asked if you want another drink as often yet she kept our drinks Full and made sure we didn't need anything else during our time there.
Can't wait to go Back!
Thanks for Making a Date Night Meal Amazing!
Donuts where the Bomb as well!

I'm a little bias because the place that was here before had like the best sandwiches in the area and suddenly someone bought the place out from under neath them, it was sad but the food here is also really good, the fried chicken is my favorite. Staff kinda just sat around talking to one another even though there was an order that needed to be bussed right in front of them. Service is kinda slow but that's understandable and it will probably get better over winter. Very cozy vibes none the less. Will definitely be coming back

Two different bartenders told us to come here on our Vermont trip. It was a little out of our way but so worth it! Best American burger ever. Best hot dog ever and so fun and cute. Wine selection was concise and modern with several orange wines! There is no sign which was a little confusing but look for the broken heart on the fence and you cannot be disappointed. Thank you

Once you've visited, it's easy to find. The first time, the signage is terrible. It felt like finding a speakeasy.
The service was good as was the food. Nice ambiance inside. I wouldn't say it was amazing. I probably won't drive out of the way to go again, but I'd be happy to eat hear again if I was passing through.

Great burger, great fries, don't like the automatic "service surcharge" of 15 % because the service was terrible. Both servers had unfriendly attitudes, couldn't even greet or smile, cheated us out of happy hour discount. Rude and unprofessional.

What a treat! Reminds me of the burgers I used to get at Stanley's in Central Falls RI back in the 70s, but better cuz there's beer on tap.

If you want an exceptional burger and fries visit Broken Hearts Burger and be sure to have the fried pickles and a craftily created donut. The food is really good, the service is friendly, and it has an all around happy, fun vibe. Fairlee is a lucky town to have this gem of a restaurant in its midst.

Wow.just wow wow wow. All the five star reviews are right but also there aren't enough stars for this place. The best food around at a price most people can afford. Don't sleep

Fantastic burgers, delightful chicken tenders crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. Delicious shoestring fries and well made comeback sauce. Great casual atmosphere with fun decor. Highly recommended.

This place is AMAZINGGGGGG! The burger was So Good I had to write about it today. And the Fries! O babyyyyyyy! Go get some u will see. YOUR WELCOME

Burger and fries were excellent. Decent beer selection. Worth noting that they charge an automatic 15% service fee even though there is no table service beyond food expediting. Even so, I will definitely go back.

Life changing burger.and OMG the fries. Did you know they have beer too? I had heard good things but it exceeded my expectations!

Great little place with a small menu that does each of the items very well. The Nashville Hot Chicken was great. It’s pricey for a burger shop (what isn’t these days?) but worth it!

It is nice to have a quality food option in the Fairlee area. The double smash burger was yummy, as was the fried chicken sandwich. Service was quick and friendly. The donuts were nice and light, though the chocolate filled one I got had no filling, which was a bummer. I'll definitely visit again. 4.5 stars.

OMG! Best burger and Fries + Fried Chicken ever! Don’t miss the pickles and matcha soft serve! What an amazing hidden gem! Can’t wait to go back. Service was spot on as well and the beverage list including, beers, ciders and wines was a well curated and diverse selection. Go! And go often

This place is awesome! Best chicken sandwich my Mom and I have had in our lives (125 years combined!), super delicious burger, and very tasty fries. I also appreciated they had a good non alcoholic beer and some great drafts available. Matt and his team are crushing it here. The place has excellent music, fun decor, and a staff with a happy vibe. Prices are reasonable and the place is often full. Highly recommended!

Fries, 4 stars (not my fav style but one point for crispy thin cut)

Donuts, 4 (needed a bit more salt, and was a touch over fermented and, but maybe that was on purpose?)

Creamy, 4 (better than most, but not as good as the best: Red Hen, Bragg Farm,)

Single burger, 5
Service, 5
Setting, 5

Heartbreaker burgers, 7 out of 5 stars!

I mean, all of it was good, but my heart already aches for another. It makes this place a destination even if everything else sucked.

Gourmet burgers in a classic setting.

We are locals and we wanted to try out this new spot, everyone has been raving about. I'd call it the best burger I ever had and the fries are perfect. Crispy and fresh. The beer selection is excellent. The service was slow, but that's because they cook to order. Go early. Service was friendly. As a Vermont native I love the vibe, truly old fashioned, like burger joints of my childhood. Like many, we love to eat local. Thanks so much for coming into town. We will be back. Thank you.

We loved everything they had to offer! We've tried to find traditional smash burgers before & none could hold a candle to The Heartbreaker! Excellent service, setting, & food! Not to mention the fresh donuts, hot fried chicken, & soft serve offerings! Just what the Upper Valley has been begging for! We will absolutely be back soon!

The Nashville spice chicken sandwich is insanely good! Old fashioned jukebox plays 60's and 70 's music. Beautiful outside seating area.

Wow! Great food, cute place, nice staff.
I got to eat the Nashville hot chicken sandwich and a classic hot dog; both were excellent. I tasted my wife’s spinach burger and fries… yup, also excellent.
Not a sub-par bite in the whole lot.
I highly recommend eating here.

Burgers are top notch! Looking forward to giving the fried chicken sandwich a try the next time I'm there. Great beer selection as well and unique soft serve flavors that are great if you want to cool down on a hot day.

I was excited to see a new business come to town, and everything about the experience exceeded my expectations. I tried both the burger and Nashville hot chicken and can't decide which I liked more. Everything was absolutely perfectly seasoned and fresh. The service was very upfront about the wait time for food when we got there, but the environment and beer list is so great we didn't even notice the wait. Highly recommend checking this place out! Get there early to make sure they have the food options you want-they're still adjusting to the demand for their delicious food and did run out of a few things when we were there.