Best Italian Restaurant in New York reviews

I don’t hate it or love it. The pizza looks amazing. The sauce and cheese is fine. The crust however felt tough because it was burnt. They also got other variety of food which I would try out.

The food and service amazing but the mouses running all over the floor where the deal breaker

I've never had better Italian food than at this restaurant. The servings are very generous! The pasta dish with vodka sauce was quite tasty! The salad was crisp and delicious! There was an amazing assortment of bread. The quality of the service...

Went for restaurant week and got one of everything (of their restaurant week menu) Starters I didn't like their bread/olives+oil, the oil itself seemed okay but the olives weren't my style and the bread was too soft for me. There was no bite...

Good experience, we ordered two dishes, one of ricotta and spinach ravioli and the other of mafaldine al ragu di funghi. It's like a corner inside Eataly, there is a bakery, a pastry shop, and there is a cannoli stand that fills it on the spot...

We ordered a margherita, white cheese, chicken buffalo, and chicken bbq slices. The guy didn’t heat them properly and when I asked him to reheat it, he was rude, rejected the request, and asked us to move to the billing counter asap. I then requested...

Very busy place, but we didn't have to wait long to be seated. Very nice and friendly place. Jason was our dining room host and he was very nice with our son. He helped us pick the best meals and drinks, and even suggested to try out the new...

My family and I have been in many many Olive Garden’s from Honolulu to New York city From Miami to Seattle and we can say this This is the best Olive Garden we have ever been in The food is amazing especially the breadsticks the best one ever We all...

Top favorite New York pizza shop ever. Crispy bottom and good taste. Every slice is top tier

Wow! The spaghetti parm was incredible. The bread that they serve the food with too is also incredible!

We went when it was not busy. Awesome place with a lot of history. The serving sizes are big and reasonably priced.

Absolutely loved this restaurant honestly can’t fault anything thanks Dayma you were fantastic 100% be back when I’m in town!

Had an amazing time here! SO fun. Was hard to get a reservation but i was able to finally get one a few weeks before hand, would recommend anyone visiting to look weeks ahead for reservation. Great staff, great comedy and very intimate.

Not sure what the hype is - it’s good pizza but nothing to shout about. Home pies with pepperoni did a good job satisfying us but the white pies weren’t my favorite. Pastas were also varying in experience. Overall not a bad spot if you want pizza in the area...

Worst service and experience- would 100% not recommend. Rude staff, absolutely inconsiderate and unfriendly. We discovered a hair in our food, and instead of admitting their error, the manager accused us and completely dismissed the issue

It is very frustrating to make a reservation for 5, the entire party is there 5 minutes early, just to be told it's going to be a very long wait. They took too many walk ins, sat the entire building. The bar couldn't keep up. The kitchen...

Family style restaurant where portions are shared. Classical Italian dishes like chicken parm, penne ala vodka, fried calamari, much more. We were a group of 20 and the restaurant did a great job accommodating everyone. Very nice from A to Z.

The food was good. I gave it a 4 because the fish was slightly overcooked on the sides. The carbonara was good. Excellent price point for the location.

Food wasn't good, pasta is way too oily, meat is dry and or tough. Service was good but there is only so much a staff can do to make up for the food. The outside of the restaurant looked very inviting though, I would recommend a drink at the...

Wonderful atmosphere and great food. Our waiter was awesome. Andrew had a terrific attitude and sense of humor. We left a sweater behind accidentally and he even ran it out to us in the parking lot!