Island Valley Golf Course

The course is in terrible shape. No fairways to speak of. Golf cart path has ruts a foot deep.

It was horrible as soon I walked in they had asked me to leave because I wasn't the right skin tone.

The best kept golf secret in Rochester. The owner rocks and the course is in great shape. We made it an annual pilgrimage to play there and played 3-4 times last summer. A great place to learn and be challenged.

This is barely even considered a golf course; it is essentially open land where someone cut grass really short in a circle to make a green. Get ready to go for a short hike on hole 5 as you walk up an uneven dirt patch that is too small for a cart and too steep for a push cart. If you’re driving a cart, make sure to bring a helmet and full body armor as the path is so uneven after hole 6; one wrong move and you’re tipping the cart and falling down a steep drop off. The greens are as short as you’d expect the fairway to be, and the fairway is worse than a lawn that hasn’t been mowed in a month. If you’re seeking danger, poor quality and a pathetic excuse for a golf course, this is the place for you!

This place is trash for 26$ the greens are almost unplayable there was no difference between the rough and fairway the cart paths are actually kind of scary to drive on just an all around awful experience and for 26 bucks there are way better courses

Suggestion. Have a more clearly guided cart path rather then yelling at customers when they don't follow it as it was my first time there. Greens were well maintained but the cart path (where it does exist) is loaded with pot holes and a hazard to drive on. Bring cash.

Probably one of the best hidden treasures in Fairport. The owner is always on site and is very friendly. If you like golf you must play here when the weather is right.

Place is cute and in the middle of the city. Looks like a hidden spot. It is fun to play these 9 holes!

$26 for 9 holes w/cart is ridiculous. Carts are seconds from death. I’ve been on better hiking trails than the “cart paths. ” Two thumbs down. We didn’t even finish the round.

Nice little golf course, although it definitely has some issues, if the price was what it used to be i wouldnt care as much but its not. Also the way you pay felt schetchy. As a warning bring bug spray mosquitoes were really bad here.

One of the worst golf courses I’ve ever went too. Paying is hard and a pain, the roads are extremely dangerous to drive carts on. The fairway is just mowed grass, and the greens are not well kept. The worst part was when we were driving a golf cart with 3 people to get our balls, the “owner” kicked us out with no warning after mentioning my yamika, and saying “we don’t serve these kind of people” Very unprofessional, and i feel like I got screwed out of my time golfing with friends. Never going here again.

Terrible owners, argued with us over simple issue. Trails on the golf course are ABSOLUTELY terrible. Cant drive without almost causing an accident.

Edit: updated to reflect current conditions of the course (terrible) and staff (rude). I used to recommend this one, but simply can't after our most recent visits.

Use to be great little course that's a nice option for beginning golfers, kids, or golfers that want to work on their short game. Overall, the length of the course is fairly short, and most holes won't require a driver, but the layout is fun, hole design is varied with a couple of really entertaining par 3's, and aside from a couple of low lying areas that take until early summer to completely dry out, course conditions are usually good. Cash only, so make sure to hit the ATM on the way over.

The "owner" of this golf facility m called my friends fat. He told them that they are “wearing out the suspension” and are lazy (because of the use of golf carts). This is unnecessary and extremely rude. The fact we are paying customers and get treated like this? Incredibly disappointing. I will never ever go here again and will be sure to tell others about this disgusting place.

Find any other place to golf!

Avoid the course at all costs.
Maintained poorly, outrages prices, and the owner enjoys harassing people on the course. If you decide to golf here, avoid the owner if possible. He is an older man with a temper, condescending attitude and is readily available with insults to your face. He confronted us, very upset, claiming that we were driving the golf cart all over the greens (which we were not BECAUSE THE GREENS WERE FULL OF MUD AND POTHOLES) and threatened to call the police for vandalism. He then began to call us lazy and fat for choosing to rent a golf cart and claimed that we were damaging the suspension on the cart! After the confrontation, he watched us from a distance for the rest of course. Genesee Valley or Eagle Vale golf course is a much better option. I will never be going here again.

Owner harasses people, scolds you if you get closer than 40 feet to the green or tee. Not giving him anymore of my business. Also threatened to call the cops because of vandalism, even though we never drove on the green with a cart.not to mention that this is not a very nice course. The greens have divots in them as well as the tees and the roads for the carts are horrible. Just go to Genesee Valley if you want a good golf experience on a budget.

GO ANY WHERE BUT HERE!
Course is poorly maintained and the owner is extremely rude. My friends and I were on the second hole of the course where the owner drove down to us on his golf cart to confront us. He said we were driving too close to the green and threatened to call the police on us for vandalism. He proceeded to call us fat by telling us we were damaging the suspension on the cart and that we were lazy for even needing a cart in the first place. We were coming here as a nice escape between finals for college but will never be coming back.