Connolly's

Good food at reasonable prices. Even real beer at reasonable NYC prices. But $9 for a Bud Light draft? LOL

Really cool and cosy pub. We sat in the main pub because there weren't any tables in the rooftop seating area and we actually preferred it there as the roof top seemed very busy and noisy - not a complaint at all, just wasn't what we were after at the time. I can tell up there is a really cool place to hang out if that's the kind of night you're after. My wife ordered the Gaelic burger and she enjoyed it while I had the potato & leek soup. We also shared some pretzels. Thoroughly enjoyed everything and appreciated the kind and attentive service by our waiter, Cian. I'm from Scotland and it's the kind of place that makes me feel at home. Definitely recommended!

Horrible customer service, they are rude and seem that they have no patience when you're looking at the menu they didn't even ask my mom what she wanted to order and completely ignored her. They rush you when you're eating and don't check in to see if you need more coffee or tea or anything. Horrible stay away. Food wasn't that great anyway and too expensive

The only downside to this place is it's proximity to Times Square which I think I am allergic to. My husband wanted an Irish Breakfast and an Irish breakfast is what we go here. A very delicious one to boot. It had everything in a traditional full Irish.

Great pub for pre- or after-show drink: full of real Irish staff and the hospitality that implies

It was OK. Had the cheese steak sandwich. Were fed up. But wouldn't come again. There are much better restaurants in the vicinity. It's more of a bar than a restaurant

Excellent environment to hang out or eat good food with friends and family, attendances very polite and friendly, recommend!

An interesting space with a neat history. We ordered fish and chips. Unfortunately they were quite greasy and the fish itself was a breaded rectangle. The beer list is quite extensive and the decor makes you feel like you're in an authentic Irish pub.

The food was amazing. This was our first time visiting and we will definitely be back. The staff was awesome as well. Definitely a must visit.

Lorraine was our waitress. We had a fabulous night here on New Year's Eve, both in the afternoon and evening, mainly due to her and the rest of the staff. Sat inside during the afternoon, out on the heated covered pavement in the evening. Food was great, chicken wings, hot pot and stew. The Irish Red ale was very drinkable. Hoghly recommended.

First class spit, very friendly staff, l8vely food and amazing customer service, what more could a man ask?

Gina is freaking awesome. She is hilarious, friendly, outgoing, and smart we love her so much we will miss her. The bar is better with her.

Perfect. Close to the hotel, just off Times Square. Delicious food from appetizers to entrees and I mean.you gotta have a beer. Oh and budget friendly for a sit down meal.

Me and my friends were here on a Sunday night. We ordered a few drinks and some sides. Food was fresh and delicious. Lorraine was our server. She was friendly, polite and treated us nicely. I was meeting my friends after a long time, she made it a memorable experience for us. So if you plan to have a few drinks with your friends, Connolly’s is the place to be. Do ask for Lorraine, she’s a sweet fun lady and is cute too.

Connolly's is a home away from home and maybe better because what happens in NYC stays in Vegas. Aside from that good time vibe, Connolly's is a solid family friendly restaurant pub. Good food, good staff. If you have a real question about Ireland or the Irish, ask the staff. They're Irish and it is glorious!

Hands down, they serve the best Shepherds pie in the city. I have tried other places, but nothing comes close to Connolly's.

The worst experience of my life. Terrible customer service, you ask for assistance, and they tell you to wait in the worst possible way, super pricey food for junk. And don't even talk about the wait. I would never recommend it for somebody to go there. In a million years, I would rather starve, and that's an understament. In addition, they automatically add the 20% tip, so they really don't care about the service.

Horrible! Sat down and didn't have a waitress come over for 30 min. I had to complain to the host. When we finally did order the eggs Benedict came out hard boiled and the Irish breakfast had raw bacon, undercooked eggs, unripe tomato, cold beans and pudding like roof shingles. Just ridiculously disappointing.

Great food and excellent service. Our drinks were never low and our waiter was very friendly and constantly checking in on us. Great spot to grab a bite near Times Square.

Great place. Bartender Patrick has lived here forever. Everything you need from an Irish Bar. We will be back when in NYC.

We just held a corporate happy hour on the historic 2nd floor of this timeless bar. Orla and her team were amazing. Prep and planning was a cinch. Will definitely be back here again for another round or 12!

Not a bad place to stop. Service was great. I've had better fish and chips, however I've had worse. Guinness was on point. Can't give 5 stars because of the meal.

Wonderful fries, delicious Gaelic burger! Beer was ice cold. A ways from home but had a great lunch. Mozzarella sticks good too! Server was pleasant. Hightoo table in a covered outdoor heated setting 4 floors up. Really enjoyed it.

Lunch and drinks. Food was good drinks were better. Staff was friendly. It was very crowded. Did not check for vaccinations and no masks.
Sat in the front near the door which was open at a high top by the stairs.

My daughter and I were visiting you New York we are from philly to see a show. We had no idea where to eat, but, we ended up at your restaurant, Keith K. The server was great, and the food was awesome! We will be back, when we visit again!

Terrible expierence! Sat at our table waiting our 45mins for a server when we asked to speak to the manager (baldy old Irish guy) he was so rude and disrespectful to my elderly mother and the other women at the table, has a serious problem dealing with complaints from women no issues taking them from men. AVOID!

Was there for an event but food and drinks were great and the staff was very helpful and friendly.

Excellent Irish pub in New York City! Standard pub fare is available as well as some unexpected choices. Friendly wait staff, good food and a perfect point of Guiness await you.

Worst service I ever had in NY for now. The manager should retire.
We called the waiter almost 5 times to order, without any response, and then, manager pull of to ask us to leave if we don’t order.

This was a neat bar/restaurant close to times Square. They had great music, plenty of options, including vegetarian meals. We really liked our waiter, he was the best.
This is a good place to go relax, have a few drinks and enjoy. Also TVs with sports.
Clean restrooms.

I’ve been here several times over the past six months, but I’ve been remiss in not reviewing Connolly’s. This time was just for a couple of drinks while I wait for my hotel room to be ready. But I’ve had dinner here twice and stopped in for just drinks twice more since May 2021. Always love the staff- friendly, like they really care that you’re here. Many have an Irish/Celtic brogue… Genuine? Beats me, but I like it. For dinner, I’ve had steak and salmon, both of which were excellent. Also had a great shrimp cocktail and crab cakes for appetizers- very good. Large selection of beers on tap- my favorite drink. Bartenders know their brews and are always helpful with recommendations. Bottom line- this is the quintessential neighborhood pub and I try to always stop I’m when I’m in NYC. I hope they never change a thing.

It was alright service. But we lost a phone in the upstairs bar. And once it closed they wouldn't search for it or let us search for it. Super lame.

Came here for dinner when going to see a comedy show and the food here is Fantastic! I got the bacon cheeseburger, My sister got the crab cakes which were amazing, and my other friend got the fish and chips Great atmosphere, attentive server! Was moderately busy but seeing how it was a Friday night that's to be expected especially being so close to Time Square. Will definitely be coming back when I am in NYC!

We’ve been sitting here for an hour. No food. On multiple occasions our food has been brought to the wrong table. People that have been here for 10mins have gotten food before us. I’ve never had such horrible service in my life. We have asked for the check and will be walking out without even having an appetizer. The waitress is sweet and trying but everyone is new and there is absolutely no organization. Do not go